false hope, fear and smear in the final legs of Green Church fight
It took local preservationists over a year to figure out that if they were serious about getting their message out, they needed to take it online; which they eventually succeeded in doing – after a failed attempt at a Committee to Save the Green Church blog – with the preservationist oriented newsletter called Bay Ridge Journal.
A blog in the loosest sense – it’s author, Kip, does not allow comments (moderated or otherwise), she does however pepper her blog with all the ingredients one would think make a good ‘New York preservationist.’ Unfortunately, stories about Jane Jacobs, food co-ops, and chicken-little ill-contextualized analysis on falling real estate prices does not a good preservationist make. One could argue, however, in the final analysis they characterize the very reason why this group has failed in their stated mission to save the beloved Bay Ridge Green Church.
Rather than taking a highly organized, reasoned, and single-issue approach as to why the Church should remain, and, more importantly, development slowed – they grab at the emotional, sentimental, and now the dishonest.
In her latest missive, Kip implies that in the course of the Church’s interior dismantling (for which “demolition” permits are not required) the community is being put at risk for asbestos poisoning, and apparently Gentile agrees – at least according to Kip. Not that we’d ever know, because communication among preservationists and Mr. Gentile are always shrouded in secrecy for whatever reason.
Interestingly enough, Bay Ridge Journal’s latest claims are made despite the fact Kip, herself, posted her own photographic evidence of duct work eminating from the church, which exists for the sole purposes of air monitoring and professional asbestos removal – which she now claims is not happening!
Meanwhile, according to the Brooklyn Eagle, Gentile says: “We’re okay with things so far, although the windows removal worries us.”
For a group whose made transparency the crux of their appeal to community leaders, the congregation and public-at-large – they seem to have trouble finding their own way in much of the same regard.
A posture which seems to be aided, in no small part, by the false hope peddled by Council Gentile, with talk of ‘secret meetings’ between his office and angel investors/buyers – only fueling a few remaining militant preservationists, and toying with an anxious congregation whose been put through the proverbial ringer.
Meanwhile, the Brooklyn Eagle reports the continuing of interior demolition of the Green Church, with the harvesting and removal of stained glass, and interior pieces – in what appears to be the final stages of its imminent demolition.
(photo courtesy: Bay Ridge Journal)











