What appears at first glance to be a convenient butt disposal bin/beer cozy for the various denizens stumbling out of Peggy’s at all hours, and the morning rush to Fanning’s for that 8am Bud (seen right, courtesy a reader) are in actuality planters for a corner tree planting initiative by the 5th avenue BID – just the latest ‘neighborhood beautification’ project in the Bay Ridge BID’s never ending pursuit to justify their existence.
The idea, carefully conceived by the various trustees of the 5th avenue BID – who no doubt have any number of hands in a landscaping, and, or metal fabrication business – will now evolve into several dozen metal projectiles for the local hooliganry.
For those of you unaware why there is such a thing as a 5th avenue BID, much less one who would do something that seems so counter intuitive to the neighborhood’s after-hour character – join the club.
To the best of our knowledge, our 5th avenue BID exists (as apparently do most) to buy trash cans, and other accessories left and right, and pay two dudes to run up and down sweeping sidewalks; which is something most small businesses did around here themselves simply as a matter of pride before the real estate and small business powers-that-be got together and decided to incorporate it. Now small businesses pay a tribute “special assessment” for said ’services.’
The Bay Ridge BID was formed in 2006 and runs from 65th street to 86th street and 5th avenue.
Among its officers are none other than local Realtors Basile Capetanakis (14 Appollo realty), Thomas McGuire (McGuire Realty); the esteemed Michael long (Conservative Party Chairman and formerly of Long’s Wines and Liquors); as well as a few other people who pretty much run everything around here.
What’s never really fully been studied is the overall impact such programs have on revitalizing or actually ‘improving’ conditions in their respective BID zones. Now, as anyone who’s had the pleasure to walk Bay Ridge’s 5th avenue can tell you – the parts that are still, well, “shit,” have remained shit despite the BID’s existence. while those parts of 5th avenue that have indeed improved, have probably done so not because of any of these so-called ’special services,’ but through real value added capital improvements by small business owners.
The relationship of BIDs to Empire Zones, of which 5th avenue from 65th to 86th is also a member, remains a unclear.
However, if BID’s perform half as well as Empire Zone’s, hopefully someone is minding the hen house other than the foxes.
In an article published last year in Crain’s New York Business -“Warning to Empire Zone Underperformers” - 400 New York City business in the city’s 11 Empire Zones were put on notice of non-compliance under the terms of the program.
Among the 404 letters sent out across NYC, Brooklyn received the most with 184 letters, in what was a sweeping investigation of the state’s largest economic development program, the “Empire State Development;” which awards tax breaks and other benefits to companies in return for their adding jobs and investing in depressed areas.